During my first attempt at online dating, I “met” this guy from California. I wasn’t used to meeting guys online at that point. Every guy I was interested in or talking to had been someone I had met amongst my social circle. This was before smartphones, Instagram, and when Facebook was just for college students. The online world was still an enigma to most people, and social media was reduced to MySpace.
I was brought to the online dating world after for working as a full-time teacher for 2-3 years and realizing the limited opportunities to meet new people were dwindling. I decided to give the online dating world a try. The first site I joined was called “Arab Lounge.” Although I wasn’t completely set on marrying an Arab, it was the only dating site with Muslims that had a decent amount of people on it. So back to Cali Guy…
I replied to his message because of how simple and flattering it was, “You seem like a sincere person.”
I remember bracing for weirdness as I went to his profile. All the messages I had gotten had been pretty weird. As I looked at his profile, I realized, he was actually pretty normal… and funny, too! I responded back with a ‘thank you’ and gave him a compliment about something I read on his profile (don’t remember exactly what it was), and he asked if we could talk on the phone. The prospect of talking to a normal guy was pretty exciting.
Our first conversation was ok. He seemed cool, but I felt like I was on some sort of job interview – “So, where do you hope to be in 5 years? What would you say is your biggest flaw? What do you like to do in your downtime?” It was pretty awkward, but unfortunately, I like talking about myself, so…
The second conversation was even more strange AND the most enlightening (the enlightenment came later). He built this hypothetical situation about walking into this party where all of these different groups of people were mingling. At a closer look, while walking around the room, you notice that all of these people, although seemingly similar, have quite different conversations from group to group. So eventually, a person would gravitate towards a particular group that they enjoyed talking to and had more in common with. Again, even if everyone seemed similar.
At the time, I was just more preoccupied with the fact that he was a normal guy, so I just acted like I got what he was trying to make me understand and acted pleasantly agreeable with just about anything he said. I felt the connection between us start to dwindle when I got the feeling that I didn’t answer some of his questions to his liking, despite my desperate efforts to impress him. I was getting ready to leave for a year-long study in Egypt, and when I offered him my number in Egypt if he ever wanted to call he responded so rudely with, “Why the hell would I call you there?” Now you may think, “Well, Meriam it IS very presumptuous to think that he’s going to call you overseas,” but his family was also from Egypt and he mentioned how he goes back to visit extended family quite often. I didn’t delude myself into thinking we were in some kind of relationship, but I did want to stay in touch. He seemed to dismiss me quite quickly, even not responding to any emails. That was my first real experience with ghosting. So when he did come to visit, I simply told him I was too busy. I wasn’t about to do what he did to me and simply ignore him, but he needed to know that his rudeness was not ok.
All of these online experiences were quite new to me. I was used to falling in “like” with guys I saw on a regular basis; not through chat and phone. It felt unnatural to me, but I wasn’t having any luck elsewhere, so what the hell.
After a string of strange online conversations with other guys, I met another guy online. I was back in the U.S. for two weeks during my year of living in Egypt. He was living in California at the time, but he grew up in Egypt. Although our first conversation left me feeling uneasy about him, he pursued me, and I gave in. My cousins also told me to “stop being so picky” and to “give him a chance.” I wish I had never listened to them. He and I spoke via Skype, chat, etc for about five months until he came to Egypt to visit his family and we met. Not only was it the most awkward meeting in my life because we didn’t know how to talk to each other in person, but I realized that I wouldn’t have been interested in him if we had met in person from the beginning. I was 26 at the time, and I didn’t understand that proximity was the most important thing for real chemistry.
Fast forward to my 30s. I’ve met lots of different people online, and have even made some friends along the way, but the vibe has shifted… for the worse.
Now that internet dating has become the norm, rules of kindness and even human decency have gone out the window. Some of my friends and I have gotten messages from guys that have opinions about our profiles, the way we dress, our professions, and even our religiosity. Although I knew FULL WELL that these jerks would never make comments like this if we were going out for coffee for the first time (or maybe some of them would), I still replied with some civility.
Not only has online dating allowed people to give unsolicited advice about our lives, but it has allowed people to completely ignore each other. If a guy clicks on the “show interest” button, then I don’t necessarily feel compelled to say anything. However, if someone messages me, even if it’s a canned message, I still respond truthfully. The main thing that really started to bother me, was how rejected I started to feel by these complete strangers. I felt that when I sent a message, it was like trying to start a conversation with them and then watching them walk away with no response like I didn’t even exist. Whenever I would share this feeling with others, I was told I was “too sensitive,” and I “expected too much.” But wasn’t I kind of supposed to expect something out of these websites? And wasn’t my being “too sensitive” allowing me to be a bit kinder to others online?
As I turned the corner into my 40s this year, I had finally started to understand the conversation I had from Cali guy years ago. The internet does not allow for the organic flow of meeting someone and having that real chemistry. It doesn’t matter the amount of complex and precise algorithms, how many questions you answer on your profile or the percentage you have in common with someone. If we were to walk into a room full of people, the conversations and attraction (both romantic and platonic) would facilitate our tendencies toward certain people more than others. Fewer people would feel fine about just ignoring someone trying to talk to them, and even fewer people would feel fine about criticizing you. Therefore you’d be able to tell who the jerks are from the beginning.
A few months ago I decided to delete all of my profiles on the many dating websites I wasted my time on over the years. The older I got, the more self-conscious I felt about my age, I got worn down by the casual meanness and opted for just hoping and praying for a more organic way of meeting someone. Being a person who feels the need to constantly control my future, this was quite the departure from my usual ways. I believe that success in everything is equal parts doing AND praying, so not incorporating the doing part is hard for me. I’m not telling everyone to suddenly give up their dating profiles – if it works for them, but it’s only had a negative effect on me. Maybe I’m “too sensitive” or maybe I do “expect too much” out of people in general, but I’m done trying to prove who I am to hundreds, thousands, millions of people who have never met me face to face.